Friday, February 5, 2010

Good Catch . . . or . . . Catch and Release?


With the recent passing of author J.D. Salinger, I am reminded of the mixed reaction that his book The Catcher in the Rye has had with many of my students. It seems that anyone that has read that book either REALLY loved it or REALLY didn't. It is interesting to me how some books can bring such different reactions to their readers. I know we usually talk about books that you like, but let's switch things up a bit and talk about a book you really didn't like for some reason. Make sure you include why you think you didn't like it so much. Be truthful, but fair.

50 comments:

  1. I did not like the book War and Peace mostly because of the seemingly boring way the book was written. The book didn't excite me and used vocabulary in a way that just made the book to confusing to enjoy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have never read a book that i didn't like i dont think. i usually only get books that i no are good or if someone has told me that they are good.

    ReplyDelete
  3. One book that I didn't like is Liar. I just recently read it and it had a good beginning, but then about 35-40 pages in it took a turn for the worse. The detail was not living up to my expectations and it just dragged on forever. i finished but it was not good. It was pretty boring and the storyline was not well written.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good Earth, by i can't remember who, was the worst book i have ever read in my entire life. Well i didn't really read it all because it was so boring. When i was reading i would have much rather been watching grass grow. It was that terrible. I hope i never have to read a book that bad every again.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really did not like the book, "The Good Earth" by Pearl S. Buck. This book just did not capture my attention and parts of it were hard to understand. Normally I don't mind history books but this one just made my eyes glaze over. In my opinion, this book was the same as reading someone's daily routine every day.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I hated reading twilight in my sophomore year. My teacher made us read it and all the girls loved it, but every guy hated it. The plot was boring in my opinion and if i wanted to read about vampires, i wouldn't read about ones that sparkle and have feelings.

    ReplyDelete
  7. One book I didn't like reading was The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. I think the main reason I didn't like it was because it was hard to understand. The characters in the book talked in a Southern dialogue which was hard to interpret. Also, the story seemed to drag on and on, and I felt like it was never going to end.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really disliked the book The Good Earth. I thought it was the most boring book I had ever read. The worst part is that I was required to read it in 10th grade. I didn't like it because it just wasn't my type of book, which made it really hard for me to comprehend.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain is one of my least favorite books because it is boring and a lot of the time you can not understand what the character is saying. Also, I'm not a fanatic of older adventure books. They usually have older terms and bigger words that I don't understand.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I didn't enjoy the book the Good Earth. My class read it for English. One of the reasons I probably didn't like it was because I was forced to read it. Also it was based in ancient China and talked the lives and customs practiced there. I'm not interested in that kind of stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Huckleberry Finn by: Mark Twain

    I didn't like the book because I found it rather boring and uninteresting. I didn't care for the plot or the scenario. The whole setting, and format didn't make me curios to know more about what happened and I dreaded the fact that I was forced to read such an unappealing book to my taste. The way Twain writes the book does not catch my attention and I'm simply not interested.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The book that I really didn't like was Tricks by: Ellen Hopkins. The book talked about the negative aspects of six teenage lives, But I was looking for more than that, I was looking for something way better than that, something more like, do they live normal or do their home lives consist of what their school life is. No, they all seem to for some reason end up in Vegas and become male and female prostitues. the book is good i'll admit, but come on could it get any more boring.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I believe the book was called Wang Lung By Pearl S. Buck. We had read this book in English our freshman year. Certain parts were interesting but all in all I was somewhat angered by the main character by the utter lack of emotion he showed toward his family. All he ever seemed to "enjoy" was his farm and when he had the money his concubines.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Wang Lung was a book about a chinese farmer and his life in China. It was really boring and nothing exciting really happened. Reading about a poor farmer and how he became wealthy did not appeal to me one bit. I didn't like this book at all.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Huckleberry Fin by: Mark Twain
    Huckleberry Fin is by far the worse book I've ever came in contact with. This book was a mandatory book Mrs. Rule made us read, of course Mrs. Rule would pick this book. The book had dialogue half of the class could not understand, even I. Huckleberry Fin didn't affect me what so ever because to this very day I could not tell you a thing about it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The book that i really didn't like was Boxes. The reason why I didn't like this book was that the main subject didn't really interest me, and also the way he wrote it. He jumped back and forth which confused me.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I didn’t care for the book Audrey Wait! by Robin Benway. When I started reading the book I thought it would be funny because it was about a girl who had an ex-boyfriend write a song about her. It ended up that it was just Audrey complaining about her horrible life the entire time. I think the author used too much sarcasm. A little sarcasm is good, but it was overdone in Audrey Wait!. It also bothered me that the author kept referring to the song written about Audrey and I didn’t know the tune of it. This made me very distracted.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Little women, it was about these women were living all alone only with their mother. The dad was in the army so he couldn't take care of them so they had to take care of themselves. One of the fell in love with a boy that loved her by.At the end of the story they get married and the dad come home because he got injured in battle. end they lived happy ever after. :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. The Adventures of Huckleberry Fin By Mark Twain.
    I dislike this book because its hard to follow and understand by all the slang words he uses. The next thing is all the stuff that couldn't happen do like the floating house. I also didn't understand the fight between the Wilks and the Grangerfords.

    ReplyDelete
  20. When I think of books that I really dislike the one that keeps coming to my mind is “Julius Caesar” by William Shakespeare. I did not admire this book at all because it seemed like every word that Shakespeare wrote was part of a word or of another language that I didn’t understand (such as nay and knave), so it would take me ten minutes to decipher one complete sentence! Maybe I’m just not smart enough to read at that level but it’s for sure the worst book/play I have ever read.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I didn’t like the book Izzy Willy-Nilly by Cynthia Voigt. In this book, the character, Izzy, is in a car crash because her driver (date) is drunk. After the accident, Izzy has one of her legs amputated. The story tells the disheartening reactions of her friends and family. I really disliked the book because I felt depressed reading about her time in the hospital. No one really cares about her and she sits alone feeling sad all day. It is hard to find excitement and lacks any real action except in the first few chapters. I didn't want to read the book because it made me sad and angry.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I think that The Good Earth was the book that i disliked. It did not interest me any. It was so long and boring, through most of the book I didn't understand much of it. Another thing was the names and how they were wrote in chinese, they were hard to pronounce.

    ReplyDelete
  23. The book Little Women because I do not really like the older style book and it was told in the girls point of view. It was a long drug out book that really didn't capture my attention.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I disliked Huckleberry Finn. For one,I don't like being forced to read a book so it made it that much worse. The real reason I didn't enjoy it was the way it was written. The book is written with wrong grammar and with a weird accent that I found hard to follow sometimes. I usually like reading historical fiction books but this was not one of my favorites.

    ReplyDelete
  25. A book that i did not like was The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn. It was a very hard book for me to relate to. The type of word choice used in this book was improper english which made it hard to understand. It was also a required book which always seems to make a book less interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Julius Caesar wad my least favorite book. Im didn't like how I couldn't understan the writing, and the fact that it was way to descriptive. I lost interest from the start, but had to try and read it for a grade in class. Also the book seemed to jump around a lot, and some of the characters names sounded or where spelled simular to other characters. This aspect made it very confusing to me.

    ReplyDelete
  27. My least favorite books that I've read were the Harry Potter series. The reason I didn't like these books is because I couldn't get myself to enjoy all the wizard-like vocabulary and I am more into the books that seem realistic. The first book of the series wasn't that horrible, but as they went on they got worse and worse and I stopped in the middle of the second one. I am just not interested in wizard and magical books.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I didn't like the book Huckleberry Fin. It didn't capture my attention and it was predictable. Also, the fact that I had to read it made it worse, since it wasn't my choice of book.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I didn't like the book Good Earth. I didn't like it because it was boring. It lacked the details that a book needs to keep my attention, and the characters weren't very interesting. It was hard to keep my attention on the book while I was reading it because my mind wandered to other things.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I didn't like the book Huckleberry Finn. Part of the reason I didn't like it was because it was so hard to understand. The words that Mark Twain used in that book were old and not easy to read. I also didn't like the book because we had to read it for an assignment in English, it wasn't a book that I could pick out based on my interests.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hatchet: By Gary Paulsen

    There wasn't really any books i didn't like. the reason is that i only pick books that i like or if they sound good on the back cover of the book, but if i don't like it i would simply put back.

    ReplyDelete
  32. A book that I really didn't like was Little Women. I really didn't like Little Women because it had a girly tone. It talked about the fashions of the 1800s and about the feelings of the girls. The feelings and fashions made me very dissatisfied with the book. The book didn't have a very good plot either. They never really accomplished much except discover who they were.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I absolutely, hands-down, did not, whatsoever, enjoy the book Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain. When I read a book, I expect some sort of gramatical rule when everyone is talking. I don't like to read a book where a person can't talk correctly (without grammar). The incorrect grammar in the book made it hard to understand what each character was saying and talking about. I don't think I'll be reading Tom Sawyer anytime soon.

    ReplyDelete
  34. There haven't been very many books that I didn't like. The one that comes to mind that I really didn't care for was Holly by Devereaux. In fact I didn't like this book so much that I've even forgotten the author's name. It was a romance I believe, and one of my friends highly recommended it, so I agreed to try it out. It lacked many details, and an original plot. The characters just didn't click for me. It just seemed like the countless romantic comedy movies I've seen. It was predictable, and I could see the ending coming a mile away. Frankly, I was not impressed.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I didn't like the book Huckleberry Finn because it was difficult to understand and it didn't interest me at all. The book was required to be read in a class so that was probably part of the reason I didn't like it and it wasn't my choice. I also thought that the book got to be long and boring.

    ReplyDelete
  36. We read The Good Earth in English 9 and I disliked it a lot. First off the book was extremely boring and never had anything interesting happen in it. All it ever talked about was the way this man lived and how he went to town everyday. I could barley read the book. Also the book was wrote in the way they talked so half of it I couldn't understand because it made no sense to me. If I had to recommend this book to anyone I would tell them not to read it because they will dislike it like I did.

    ReplyDelete
  37. The book I didn't like was Julius Caesar. I didn't like reading that because of the grammar. It was hard to figure out what Shakespeare was trying to make the characters in the book say. Even after the teacher translated what the characters were trying to say, there was just something about the book that I didn't like. I also didn't quite comprehend everything that was happening in the book either.

    ReplyDelete
  38. A book I really didn't like was this really boring poem book my LA teacher made us read in 8th grade. I don't remember what its name was, but I do remember that for a whole term we just read boring poems out of that poem book. That was the worst experience I ever had in an LA class. I think I really didn't like the book because the whole thing was filled with horrible poems.

    ReplyDelete
  39. In 8th grade reading we read Drivers Ed by someone. You had said that this book had been a big hit in previous years. I HATED THIS BOOK. I don’t particularly know why but it just seemed like it was the same ideas over and over again. Girls chasing this guy the boring drivers Ed teacher, this book just went on and on and on. The only interesting part is when they stole the stop sign, and a woman was killed. I thought it was sad that a person had to die for me to be interested in a book. My entire group felt the same way and when it came time to rate this book it received no more than a 3.

    ReplyDelete
  40. A book I really didn't like was Heir Apparent. Somebody recommended I read it, so I decided I would give it a try. I remember that it was based in the future and it was about a girl who was in some crazy video game. It was a virtual reality game and it broke and she had to finish the game before she could get out of the game. It was sort of sci-fi and a little ridiculous. I think the reason I didn't like it was because it was so strange. I don't really like books about sci-fi and that kind of stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  41. I didn't like the book The Good Earth by Pearl S. Buck because it didn't capture my attention at all. I was bored as I read it and didn't understand what was going on some of the time. There wasn't much dialogue, if any, and I didn't like reading it in 3rd person. Mostly, the topic of the book just wasn't very interesting to read about.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Streams of Babel
    by Carol Plum-Ucci

    I read the book Airborne, and didn't really like it. It was an ITA nominee so I decided to read it. I didn't like it, because it didn't really make sense. There was never a reason given to why the airship was attacked, or what happened after they left the island. It was going on getting to the climax when it just ended. We never found out what happened they leave the island.

    ReplyDelete
  43. A book that I really didn't like was the Good Earth. I don't even remember what it was about so i couldn't have interested me too much. I thought the book had no importance to me so I wasn't very interested.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I usually do my best to read books I do like and if I don't like them I give up after a while, but once it was recommended that I read the short story "To Build a Fire." Thankfully it was short, but I read the whole story waiting for an exciting ending, though it was really just about arrogance and ignorance. It was another one of those pieces of literature that, to me, are boring because they are only trying to make a point or write creatively or encourage you to think about what you've read. These are things I am willing to read only if they are entertaining at the same time. It disappointed me in the same way Huck Finn did. It didn't really seem to go anywhere

    ReplyDelete
  45. Allen secrets by.Annette Curtis Klause

    Allen secrets by Annette Curtis Klause is not a book that I like. The reason is because the story dose not sound real like some of the Gary pulson books. I would classify this book as hoer. With that being said that is probably one of the main points that i did not like that book.

    ReplyDelete
  46. The Good Earth
    I didn't like it because it never really grabbed my attention. The characters were not interesting and didn't stick out. The Good Earth was a book we had to read in English.

    ReplyDelete
  47. A book that I really hated was Mein Kampf (my mind in German) By Adolf Hitler. He just talks about the same stuff over and over and over again, and I could only get to page 100 out of 500 before I threw it down in anger.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Sorry, Mien Kampf is my struggle, not my mind.

    ReplyDelete
  49. A book that I didn't like was The Good Earth. We had to read it in 9th grade because I never really got into the book. It was boring to read because i like books with a lot of things going on in them.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Little Woman

    I didn't like the book because it was really boring and didn't have a lot of action or adventure in it. for a book to intrest me it needs to have these things.

    ReplyDelete

Posting Instructions
When posting a comment, please choose the "Name/URL" identity option in the drop down menu, unless you have a Google or Blogger account. Please post your first name and last name initial only, do not put anything in the URL field. Comments may not appear immediately as they may be moderated. Anonymous comments will not be posted. Thanks!
Older Post Home
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Subscribe To